There were countless rumors of infidelities and third parties in the couple made up of the Colombian singer Shakira and the Barcelona footballer Gerard Piqué. Now users of social networks and fans of both the athlete and the artist are looking for signs on social networks, more specifically on Instagram to discover where the conflicts between the two members of the couple began.

In one of Shakira’s latest publications, the Colombian singer showed herself in a photo with the father of her two children. The Instagram post was to celebrate nothing more and nothing less than February 14. “Happy Valentine’s Day,” Shakira wrote along with a photo in which she can be seen with her former partner De Ella Gerard Piqué.

A month after this post, the athlete celebrated having played 600 games with his club’s shirt. Shakira also dedicated a post to him on this occasion highlighting the human quality of Gerard Piqué and his performance and quality as a footballer. “Your achievements have no precedent. History is a continuous present and you are here to continue forging yours, your clubs, ours, and that of future generations,” the singer wrote proudly.

Shakira also added: “You are made of a material that only God knows and for me you are the best example of struggle, perseverance, and sincerity for our children. During these years with you I have realized that you came to this world to change paradigms. There is not, nor will there be another Gerard Piqué. An exceptional human being.”

After this post, after a week Shakira uploaded another photo of Gerard Piqué to her Instagram and wrote: “ Gerard doesn’t let me say these things publicly. But only he, with his heroism, can play like this, overcoming any injury or pain and always giving his best. It’s not because he’s my husband, but he’s the best center back in the world. I said!”.