Entertainment

I Play Rocky: The True Story of How Sylvester Stallone Fought to Star in Rocky, and Who Plays Him

Peter Farrelly's I Play Rocky dramatises how Sylvester Stallone, an unknown actor, refused to give up the lead in the film he wrote. Here is the cast, the true story and the reviews.

I Play Rocky: The True Story of How Sylvester Stallone Fought to Star in Rocky, and Who Plays Him

Fifty years after Rocky first hit cinemas, Hollywood has made a film about how it almost never happened, at least not with Sylvester Stallone in the ring. I Play Rocky, directed by Peter Farrelly (Green Book), is in cinemas now, with newcomer Anthony Ippolito playing the young Stallone.

What is I Play Rocky about?

In the mid-1970s Stallone was a struggling actor with a script about a small-time boxer who gets a shot at the world title. Studios liked the script but wanted a bankable star in the lead, and offered Stallone more and more money to step aside.

Advertisement

He refused. “I play Rocky” was his condition. Producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff eventually agreed and made the film on a tiny budget. Rocky became the biggest film of 1976 and won three Oscars, including Best Picture.

I Play Rocky cast

  • Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone
  • AnnaSophia Robb as Sasha Czack, Stallone’s wife
  • Jay Duplass as John Avildsen, the director of Rocky
  • Tracy Letts as studio boss “Sandy Maddox”
  • Matt Dillon as Frank Stallone Sr.
  • Stephan James as Carl Weathers
  • Kiki Seto as Talia Shire
  • Toby Kebbell and P.J. Byrne

The screenplay is by Peter Gamble, and the film is released by Amazon MGM Studios.

Who is Anthony Ippolito?

Ippolito was a little-known actor before this role, and he won it in a very Stallone way. Rather than waiting for an audition, he filmed his own unsolicited scenes as Stallone and sent them in, a move he has compared to Stallone’s own refusal to take no for an answer. Stallone met Farrelly before filming began.

What do the critics say?

The film premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival in September and was Certified Fresh at 88% on Rotten Tomatoes from its first reviews, with a 98% audience score.

  • The praise: Ippolito’s performance is the headline. Awards Radar suggested he “might also end up an Oscar nominee for this one”.
  • The criticism: some critics found it too sweet and simplified. TheWrap called it “a hollow crowdpleaser”, and WBUR said it plays loose with the facts.

In short, most critics see it as a feel-good underdog story with a star-making lead performance, even if it is not a strictly accurate history lesson.

How true is I Play Rocky?

The core of the story is true: Stallone wrote Rocky, studios wanted a bigger star, and he insisted on playing the role himself. But the film takes liberties. The studio boss played by Tracy Letts, for example, is a renamed version of United Artists head Arthur Krim, and some critics say the drama has been heavily simplified.

Rocky by the numbers

  • Released: 1976
  • Oscars: 3 wins, including Best Picture and Best Director for John Avildsen
  • Oscar nominations for Stallone: Best Actor and Best Original Screenplay
  • Franchise: six Rocky films plus the Creed series

Frequently asked questions

Who plays Sylvester Stallone in I Play Rocky?

Anthony Ippolito.

Is I Play Rocky a true story?

Yes, it is based on the true story of how Stallone got Rocky made, though some details are changed.

Who directed I Play Rocky?

Peter Farrelly, the Oscar-winning director of Green Book.

Is I Play Rocky good?

Most critics like it. It was Certified Fresh at 88% on Rotten Tomatoes after its first reviews.

Sources: Rotten Tomatoes (first reviews), WBUR, TheWrap review, Further and Better (industry round-up)

Advertisement
Share this story
Written byGeekyBar Desk

The GeekyBar Desk covers entertainment, celebrity and streaming news, from Hollywood and Bollywood to Netflix and Marvel.

More from Entertainment